Originally Posted by
Malamute
I pocket carried a 640 for a few years, then found a 1980s Colt Agent, which instantly became my favorite pocket carry gun, even with Pachmayr Compac grips. It splits the difference between J and K frame while giving 6 rds and has a very comfortable grip. If the recoil became a problem with it I think id try a steel frame Colt D frame, namely a Detective Special. I think the K is a bit more than I want to pocket carry, YMMV of course.
Edit: you might give some different grips a try on your current gun. They may not be optimal for carry ease, but may get you able to shoot it again without the pain. I never considered the Pachmayrs on a J, but they definitely make it easier to shoot. Ive been pleasantly surprised on how well the Colt with Pachmarys has worked out for pocket carry, as its the best grip ive found for it to shoot. Im able to do it with no holster or a milk jug holster with minimal low end protrusion so it sits low enough it doesnt show. The speedloader in the pocket keeps it in place for the most part.
Theres also older Colt Detective Specials and Police Positives (same frame with longer barrel, like 3"+) in 32 cal for somewhat reasonable prices. Colt called the 32 S&W long 32 Colt NP or New Police. One such gun with finish challenges would probably be the donor gun for my wanna-be Diamondback 32 project. In the Colt line, a Cobra or Agent is the alloy frame version in the older small D frames
Yes, Im somewhat new gun challenged. If anything newish strikes an interest, I tend to look for older versions of the same type or concept, and they are often less money.
When my injury happened, I felt like I aged about 15 years in a short time. Its been a bit over 10 years now. I had thought about geezer guns before, but also didnt expect to actually need them so soon.